The story of how I  created a hugely popular meme website and then failed (fail being the operative word throughout this article) to make any money from it. Warning: also includes lolcats. </p>

It started when I read something about a girl making $70,000 a month from a MySpace graphics service.

This got me thinking about the value (or not) of “good” design.

What if I booted my usual aesthetic standards out of the window and went lowest common denominator with a blog?

I figured that an anti-design experiment would be fun.  

But first I needed some subject matter. 

Around this time I was seeing a lot of “fail” images cropping up on the forum I was hanging out on, so I thought it would be fun to collect them together in a blog. 

If you’ve spent any time on less serious areas of the internet (say on forums like 4chan) you won’t need an explanation of the fail meme. 

As far as I can tell the fail boat meme, which as the starting point for Shipment of Fail, originated in 2007 with an image of a sinking boat that was captioned “All aboard the failboat”.

The fail meme itself is much older of course — the entry for “fail” in the urban dictionary has been in place since 2003 — and there are all kinds of variations of the meme out there in the wild.

Blogging fail pictures seemed like it could be a win. 

And for once I was ahead of the curve: “” was available. So I registered the domain and installed a generic (read: ugly) Wordpress theme and set about blogging fail images.  

Shipment of Fail was born. 

The whole thing was incredibly cathartic for me at first.

My day job involved designing things to within a pixel of their life. Or to within a pixel of my own life. Does anyone other than a graphic designer ever look at a website and think “Holy crap. That thing is a pixel out of place!”. Probably not.  

But with SOF everything was lowest common denominator. This was base humour. This was an ugly son of a bitch and I didn’t care.   

Meme aesthetics require the use of big, bold fonts like Impact. In capitals. With a huge white strokes around them for good measure. Basically the opposite of my usual typographic output.

So there I was, uploading a cheesy new fail picture every day or so, with captions slapped across them IN HUGE CAPITAL LETTERS.

Then, to promote my new blog, I began to post a few images onto a few forums. 

I didn’t expect much to happen. 

Shipment of Fail goes viral

Then I looked at my stats. 

Traffic was going up. Fast. 

At the peak of its popularity, SOF had an Alexa rank of around 77,000.

Which meant it was amongst the top 100,000 most popular websites on the internet, with around 5,000 people visiting a day. 

At one point I was contacted by a broadsheet journalist and SOF was included in the pullout section of a weekend newspaper. 

Shipment of Fail was big. 

I was dumbfounded. 

The worst designed website I’d ever created was the most popular.  

Everything I thought I knew about the importance of design had been blown out of the water. 

I didn’t do anything to promote my site after the initial few forum postings that I made.

There was no email marketing strategy.

But the content marketed itself of course… it was perfect for posting in forums. Memes are good like that.

Without much thought I stuck some Google Adverts into the SOF sidebar and waited to see what advertising revenue I could earn.

On a good day I would make £6 or £7.

Which was enough to buy myself a couple of beers at that time.

Not a bad return for the 10 minutes it took to select and upload a fail image.

Blogging boredom

The novelty quickly wore off of course. I was constantly trawling through forums looking for fail images.

There’s only so much fail a man can take.

So I decided to offload SOF for as much money as I could get.

One of the first people I reached out to was Ben Huh, the man behind the Cheezburger Network, a sprawling meme empire empire which with the I Can Has Cheezburger? lolcat site at its heart.

Here’s the email that came back from Ben: 

Hey James,
I think we can offer you $518.00 for the site. Let me know if this works.

I didn’t feel this was enough considering the amount of work I’d put into the site.

So I turned down the LOLcats entrepreneur and set about selling SOF myself.

And so to auction...

I decided that auctioning the site off would be the best option. 

Someone left a comment on the auction thread suggesting I could increase the sale price by improving the look of the site a little. (Which, amazingly to me, was probably the first time anyhow had criticised it). 

So I bought a budget Wordpress theme and knocked up a 15 minute logo: a crate with “Shipment of Fail” stencilled onto it. 

The auction process began and a few days later the winning bid was confirmed as $500. 

Hmm. Not as much as I had hoped.

But I needed the money and decided to cut my losses and cash in. 

My blogging shipment of fail

Looking back, there were a few things I could have done differently or better.  

  1. I never got round to building a "fail generator",  eg a way for readers to upload an image, caption it, and then submit it to the site. I Can Haz Cheezburger does this to great effect. I often thought about it but then balked at the cost (which would have been fairly negligible if I'd outsourced it). If your blog makes use of user-generated content, be sure to make it as easy as possible for your users to generate said content! (duh!)
  2. On which note, I could probably have outsourced most of the blogging process itself, leaving myself to make 'editorial' decisions. This wouldn't have cost much given the simplicity of the content, and would have led to increased traffic and advertising revenue.
  3. I never sold any of my own merchandise. They're not something that I would have personally wanted to wear, but I'm sure that "Shipment of fail" tshirts would have gone down a treat with my readers. Or SOF mugs with a fake crack printed onto them. The tackier the better. A blog is not a business: if your blog is intended to be commercial, get your thinking cap on before you start blogging about what information or products you can sell to your audince.
  4. I didn't really engage with my readers. They actually left a lot of comments, even if they were relatively throwaway. But I didn't bother to respond to them.
  5. I didn't build up a mailing list. At one point I had almost 20,000 people subscribing via Feedburner. Imagine if I had converted half of them to email subscribers. That would have been a huge platform to work from. And email is the single most effective way of communicating with people online.
  6. I wasn't willing to invest any money in growing the blog. If I'd outsourced some of the content generation, or found guest bloggers, or got the really engaged fans to help out, I could have done a lot more with the site. 
  7. I chose a subject I wasn't interested in for the long run. Content generation is a marathon, not a sprint, so you have to chose your topic very carefully.  
  8. I rushed to sell. With a bit more patience, and with steps (1.) and (2.) above implemented, I could have carried on growing the blog for at least a few months before trying to sell it.  

Anyhow. What’s done is done. SOF was never going to be a long-term career, I don’t think. 

Experiments can't fail

I kept in touch with the guy that I sold SOF to. 

A year later I found out that he had sold the site on for $5,000. 

10 times more than I had sold it to him for. 

 Shipment of fail dot com.

But you know what, I’m kind of glad now that SOF failed; or rather that I failed to make a nice little chunk of cash from it.

I won’t make these mistakes again if I ever end up selling my current blog. (And in fact, starting a blog with the intention of selling it is a pretty stupid thing to do in the first place).

In fact I’m probably doing myself a disservice by calling SOF a fail.

It was only ever intended an experiment… and experiments can’t fail, because they are just a way to evaluate information, to dip your toes in the water, to run some tests.  

So, go and make your own fails happen.

Embrace the shipments of fail.

(But remember that they are really just experiments).


Posted to life in 2013.

Join 2,474 readers receiving my thoughts on life, design and making stuff happen each Sunday